Lchatchilah, you should wait for the 10th person to come to shul and only then start the Amida. However if you didn't wait and the 10th person arrived after…
Lchatchilah, you should wait for the 10th person to come to shul and only then start the Amida. However if you didn't wait and the 10th person arrived after…
Question: What to do in a situation that the 10th person walks in to Shul, after everyone (the nine men) finished Shmone Esrei and there has definitely been a…
Yes. כמפורש ברמב״ם תפלה י, יג שחוזר לראש אחד יחיד ואחד ציבור. וכ״כ ברא״ש ברכות א, טז, ובשו״ת הרשב״א א, לה. וכן הביא בלקט יושר ע׳ כא, שהורה…
He should go back unless he already said Boruch Ata Hashem. ערך השולחן טייב קכז, א בשם המאירי מגילה כד, ב (לפני משנה ו), ושם הביאו בשם הגאונים. והו״ד…
כ״כ כדבריו במסגרת השולחן. אבל שמועה רווחת בשם כ״ק אד״ש - ונדפס בקובצי ההערות- לעשות כבשו״ע. וכ״ה בשיחות קודש קודם הנשיאות ע׳ 182. אלא שצע״ג אם השמועה מדוייקת. …
1. Is there a need for six people to be holding with the minyan at the time of Borchu? No. See here: https://asktherav.com/3310-at-which-point-must-the-chazzan-wait-for-at-least-six-to-be-with-the-minyan-before-continuing/ 2. To start Chazoras Hashatz,…
In order to be considered Tefilah B'Tzibur there need to be at least six men davening Shmonah Esrei together. If there were no six people davening together, then one…
In Chazars Hashatz of (Shachris and Mussaf of) Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur there are two parts, the Tefilah and the Piyutim/Slichos. During the Tefilah, the Chazzan must say…
Assuming this logic, when someone is behind the Minyan and holding in a place where he could (must) answer Amen to Chazaras Hashatz (like in Pesukei D'zimra), would he have…
