AskTheRav
  • Browse
    • Yearly Cycle
      • Rosh Chodesh
      • Pesach
      • Pesach Sheini
      • Shavuos
      • The 3 Weeks
      • Rosh Hashana
      • Yom Kippur
      • Sukkos
      • Chanukah
      • Purim
    • Life Cycle
      • Birth
        • Pregnancy
        • Birth
        • Bris Milah
        • Shalom Zachar
        • Pidyon Haben
      • Upsherinish
        • Upsherin
        • Hachnasa L’Cheider
        • Chinuch
      • Birthday
      • Bar Mitzvah
      • Marriage
        • Shidduchim
        • Wedding
        • Chanukas Habayis
        • Mezuzah
      • Wills
      • Mourning (Aveilus)
    • לפי סדר השלחן ערוך
      • אורח חיים
        • חלק א
          • שאר מיני ברכות
            • רכח: ברכת ימים ונהרות הרים וגבעות
        • חלק ב
          • הלכות שבת
            • מלאכות שבת
              • שכח – דיני חולה בשבת
          • הלכות עירובין
        • חלק ג
          • תפט
        • חלק ד
      • יורה דעה
        • הלכות מאכלי עכו”ם
          • סימן קכ: דיני טבילת הכלים
          • סימן קכא: סדר הכשר כלים הנקנים מן העובד כוכבים
        • הלכות מזוזה
          • סימן רפה: שכר מצות מזוזה
          • סימן רפו: מקומות החייבים במזוזה
          • סימן רפז: איזו פתח חייב במזוזה
          • סימן רפח: במה והיאך נכתבת
          • סימן רפט
            • סעיף א: ברכתה
            • סעיפים ב-ג: מקום קביעותה
            • סעיפים ד-ו: כיצד קובעה
          • סימן רצא: מזוזה מתי נבדקת
      • אבן העזר
      • חושן משפט
        • הלכות הלואה
        • הלכות מכירה
        • הלכות אונאה וגניבת דעת
        • הלכות מציאה
        • הלכות צער בעלי חיים
        • הלכות גזלה וגנבה
        • הלכות נזקי ממון
        • הלכות נזקי גוף ונפש ודיניהם
        • הלכות שמירת גוף ונפש
        • הלכות בל תשחית
    • Quick Links
      • Women
      • Brachos List
      • Muktza List
      • Can an Avel (Mourner)…
      • Do I need to Toivel a…
    • Full Database
    • Halacha2go Archives
  • My Questions
    • Sign Up
    • Sign In
  • Members
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Publications
Submit A Question

Tagged as: minyan

  • Davening, Sukkos
  • minyan, או"ח תרלט

האם מותר להתפלל בבית ביחיד בסוכה בשביל לא לצאת מהסוכה?

  שאלה: אדם שמקפיד לא לצאת מהסוכה. האם מותר להתפלל בבית ביחיד בסוכה בשביל לא לצאת מהסוכה. עין בשועה"ר תרלט ס"ה, כותב שאם יש בית הכנסת ילך לבית הכנסת ואינו…

Continue Reading

  • Shema
  • Hashem Elokeichem Emes, minyan

Is a Minyan needed for the Chazan to Motzei the Kahal with Hashem Elokeichem Emes?

  I daven in a small minyan where time is a concern. Today the 10th guy went to the restroom by shema. Question: Can the chazan be motzei the kahal…

Continue Reading

  • Chazaras Hashatz, Davening, Shemoneh Esrei
  • Chazoras Hashatz, davening, minyan

If we have 9 people for a Minyan and the 10th is on the way to shul, can we start the Amida or do we need to wait for 10th? Can we do repetition?

  Lchatchilah, you should wait for the 10th person to come to shul and only then start the Amida. However if you didn't wait and the 10th person arrived after…

Continue Reading

  • Krias Hatorah, Shabbos
  • minyan, Shabbos

May one make a minyan on Shabbos afternoon only for Kriyas Hatorah, without davening Mincha?

    Yes, a Minyan just for Kriyas Hatorah may be done for Mincha of Shabbos. The only change would be that a Chatzi Kaddish would be said right after…

Continue Reading

  • Mental Health, Minyan
  • Autism, minyan

Can I count an autistic boy for a Minyan?

  When it comes to counting someone with mental special needs (autism, down syndrome, etc.) for a Minyan, it all depends on the specific individual’s level of understanding and comprehension.…

Continue Reading

  • Davening, Shul
  • minyan

I walk too far from Shul to walk there on Shabbos…

  Question: I live 1 hour and 15 minute walk from Shul. I drive there during the week. I feel uncomfortable walking there mincha & maariv at night. only Shachris…

Continue Reading

  • Davening
  • Covid-19, minyan, zoom

How important is it to Daven at the time of a Minyan on Zoom?

  Full Question: I read the following links (1/2), and my question is: How important is it to try and schedule our home davening around the schedule of a Zoom…

Continue Reading

  • Davening
  • Covid-19, minyan

אני בשעת אבילות שמעתי שעושים מנינים דרך zoom app. האם מותר לעשות מנין להתפלל ולומר הקדשים?

  מנין באופן כזה אינו מועיל. ו״צריך שיהיו כל העשרה במקום אחד ושליח צבור עמהם, אבל אם מקצתם בחדר זה ומקצתם בחדר אחר אינם מצטרפים״ - שוע"ר סי' נה סעי' טו.…

Continue Reading

  • Uncategorized
  • -, Covid-19, minyan

Dear Rabbi, Why do the shuls need to be closed? Why are even the outdoor Minyanim banned?

  Dear Rabbi, I have thought all my life that one needs to listen to Rabbi’s and doctors, but I have searched the CDC website and I have not seen…

Continue Reading

  • Davening, Medical
  • 770Live, Covid-19, minyan, quarantine

What is the ideal way to daven when one is in quarantine?

  Teffilah Betzibur can be done by joining in and Davening at the time the Tzibur are Davening, preferably at the time you know a specific Minyan is Davening, such…

Continue Reading

  • Davening, Shacharis
  • kaddish, minyan

I am aware that if people left Shul in middle of Chazoras Hashatz and there is no longer a Minyan, we may finish Chazroas Hashatz and also Kaddish after U’Va L’Tziyon. My question is can we also say the other Kaddeishim, or it only applies to that one Kaddish?

  The Kaddeishim after Shir Shel Yom and onward are not considered גמר תפלת י"ח ("the culmination of Shemoneh Esreh") and therefore should only be said if there's a Minyan present…

Continue Reading

  • Davening
  • aleinu, minyan

Joining the Minyan for Aleinu

  Question: When the Minyan starts saying Aleinu, but I'm still in the middle of Ashrei/U'va Letzion/Shir shel Yom/Kave, do I stop my davening and say Aleinu with the Minyan…

Continue Reading

  • Chazaras Hashatz, Davening
  • minyan

I regularly daven in a Minyan with exactly 10 people, and I had a few questions:

  1. Is there a need for six people to be holding with the minyan at the time of Borchu? No. See here: https://asktherav.com/3310-at-which-point-must-the-chazzan-wait-for-at-least-six-to-be-with-the-minyan-before-continuing/   2. To start Chazoras Hashatz,…

Continue Reading

  • Chazaras Hashatz, Davening
  • minyan, six mispalelim, Tefilah B'Tzibur, Yishtabach

At which point must the Chazzan wait for at least six to be with the Minyan before continuing?

  In order to be considered Tefilah B'Tzibur there need to be at least six men davening Shmonah Esrei together. If there were no six people davening together, then one…

Continue Reading

  • Davening
  • minyan, Tefillah B’Tzibbur

The Rebbe said that merely starting Tefillah with the Tzibbur constituted Tefillah B’Tzibbur. What is the source for this?

  The Rebbe said it’s מעין תפלה בציבור. It is not considered תפלה בציבור in the literal sense. This idea has parallels in many places. See also שו״ת בית יעקב…

Continue Reading

  • Chazaras Hashatz, Davening
  • answering amen to chazaras hashatz, chazaras hashatz, davening, minyan, shemoneh esrei

Can One Daven During Chazaras Hashatz?

  Question: The Alter Rebbe writes in the Siddur “Lo Yafa Heim” about people that learn or say Tachanunim during Chazaras Hashatz, even if they listen to the end of…

Continue Reading

  • Davening, Shemoneh Esrei
  • chazaras hashatz, davening, minyan, prison, shemoneh esrei, tefila, או"ח סט

We are making a Minyan in a prison for RH and YK. If we have a Minyan but not 6 people Davening the Amida can they still do Chazaras Hashatz since we are dealing with people that don’t know how to Daven?

  In order to do Chazraras Hashatz, there need to be at least 6 people who Davened Shemoneh Esrei. If there weren't 6 people who Davened, then the Chazan should…

Continue Reading

Sponsored By:
Categories
  • – Archives
  • – Charts
  • – Halacha Articles
  • – אידיש
  • – עברית
  • Ahavas Yisroel
  • Avodah Zarah
    • Gentiles
    • Kishuf
    • Non-Jewish Activities
    • Peyos (Haircut)
  • Bar Mitzvah
  • Beard
  • Beis Hamikdosh
  • Birth
    • Names
    • Pregnancy
    • Pru U'rvu
  • Birthday
  • Bris Milah
  • Chabad Minhogim
  • Chanukah
    • How to Light Menorah?
    • Menorah & Candles
    • When to Light the Menorah?
    • Where to Light Menorah?
    • Who Should Light Menorah?
  • Children-Chinuch
  • Chinuch
  • Chol Hamoed
  • Choshen Mishpat
    • Borrowing
    • Damages
    • Employer and Employee
    • Geneivas Daas
    • Hasagas Gevul
    • Hashavas Aveida
    • Intellectual Property
    • Loans
    • Nizkei Guf V'Nefesh
    • Renting
    • Sales
    • Shmiras Guf V'Nefesh
    • Stealing
  • Chumros
  • Customs
  • Davening
    • Amen
    • Birchas Kohanim
    • Birchos Hashachar
    • Chazaras Hashatz
    • Gartel
    • Hefsek in Davening
    • Kaddish
    • Kavana
    • Kedushah
    • Krias Hatorah
      • Aliyos
    • Maariv
    • Mechitzah
    • Mincha
    • Minyan
    • Pesukei D'Zimrah
    • Shacharis
    • Shema
    • Shemoneh Esrei
    • Tachanun
    • Tallis
    • Teffilas Haderech
  • Divrei Kedusha
  • Food
  • Geirus
  • Hafrashas Challah
  • Hashem's Name
  • Kashrus
    • Bugs
    • Fish and Meat
    • Fish and Milk
    • Food
    • Health Supplements
    • Hechsher
    • Kashering
    • Kitchen
    • Meat and Milk
      • Time Between Milk/Meat
    • Medicine
    • Orlah
    • Ovens
    • Stam Yeinom – Wine
  • Kibud Av V'Em (Honoring Parents)
  • Kilayim
    • Shatnez
  • Lashon Hara
  • Lifnei Iver
  • Lo Yilbash
  • Ma'acholei Akum (Food of Gentiles)
    • Bishul Yisroel
    • Cholov Yisroel
    • Pas Yisroel
    • Tevilas Keilim
  • Marriage
    • Shidduchim
    • Wedding
  • Meal
    • Bentching (Birchas Hamazon)
      • Zimun
    • Brochos (Birchas HaNehenin)
      • Besamim
      • Hagomel
    • Netilas Yodayim (Seudah)
  • Medical
    • Alternative Medicine
    • Mental Health
  • Mezuzah
  • Mikvah (Men)
  • Minhogim
  • miscellaneous
  • Mivtzoyim
  • Morning Conduct
  • Moshiach
  • Mourning (Aveilus)
    • Burial
    • Shiva
    • Shloshim
    • Yahrtzeit
    • Year of Aveilus
  • Nachalos (Inheritance)
  • Nedorim (Vows)
  • Negel Vasser
  • Pesach
    • Bedikas Chometz
    • Chometz
    • Daled Koisos
    • Kashering (Pesach)
    • Maos Chitim
    • Matzah
    • Mechiras Chometz
    • Pesach Cleaning
    • Seder
  • Pidyon Haben
  • Purim
    • Costumes
    • Matanos L'Evyonim
    • Megillah
    • Mishloach Manos
    • Seudah
    • Taanis Esther
      • Machatzis Hashekel
  • Ribbis (Interest)
  • Rosh Chodesh
    • Kiddush Levana
  • Rosh Hashana
    • Hataras Nedarim
    • Shofar
    • Simanim
    • Tashlich
    • Teffilos
  • Safrus
  • Sakanah
  • Sefer Torah
  • Sefiras HaOmer
    • Clothing
    • Counting Omer
    • Crossing Dateline
    • Haircut
    • Lag Ba'Omer
    • Music
  • Seforim
  • Selichos
  • Shabbos
    • Amira L'nachri
    • Animals
    • Borer
    • Carrying
    • Cleaning
    • Coloring
    • Cooking
    • Cosmetics
    • Eiruv
    • Erasing
    • Food
    • Havdala
    • Hotel
    • Kiddush
    • Kitchen Appliances
    • Kneading (Losh)
    • Measuring
    • Muktzeh
    • Musical Instruments
    • Refuah
    • Seder Hayom of Shabbos
      • Erev Shabbos
      • Mincha
      • Motzei Shabbos
    • Shabbos Candle Lighting
    • Shnayim Mikrah
    • Squeezing
    • Tearing
    • Travel
    • Tying
    • Washing
    • Writing
  • Shavuos
  • Shechita
  • Sheimos (Genizah)
  • Shiurim (Classes)
  • Shlichus
  • Shmitah
  • Shul
    • Mechitzah
  • Sleep
    • Krias Shema Al Hamita
  • Sukkos
    • Daled Minim
    • Schach
    • Sukkah
  • Taanis Tzibur (Fast Days)
  • Tahara for a Kohen
  • Taharas Hamishpacha
    • Calendar
    • Harchokos
    • Maros
    • Mikvah (Women)
    • Shiva Nekiyim
  • Talmud Torah
    • Chumash
    • Kriah (Alef-Beis & Nekudos)
  • Tefillin
  • Tehillim
  • Terumos and Ma'asros
  • The 3 Weeks
    • Haircut
    • Music
    • Nine Days
    • Shopping
    • Swimming
    • Tisha B'Av
  • Tzar Baalei Chaim
  • Tzavoas Reb Yehuda HaChossid
  • Tzedaka
    • Maaser
      • Separating Ma’aser
      • Spending Ma'aser
  • Tzitzis
  • Tznius
    • Dress Code
    • Kol Isha
    • Negiah
  • Uncategorized
  • Upsherin
  • Wills
  • Women
  • Yichud
  • Yom Kippur
    • Davening
    • Fasting
    • Kaporos
  • Yom Tov
    • Candle Lighting
    • Carrying
    • Chol Hamoed
    • Cooking
  • Zmanim
AskTheRav
© Copyright: AskTheRav.com, All Rights Reserved.
Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy