AskTheRav
  • Browse
    • Publications
    • Rambam
    • Categories
    • Yearly Cycle
      • Rosh Chodesh
      • Pesach Homepage
      • Pesach Sheini
      • Shavuos
      • The 3 Weeks
      • Rosh Hashana
      • Yom Kippur
      • Sukkos
      • Chanukah
      • Purim Homepage
    • Life Cycle
      • Birth
        • Pregnancy
        • Birth
        • Bris Milah
        • Shalom Zachar
        • Pidyon Haben
      • Upsherinish
        • Upsherin
        • Hachnasa L’Cheider
        • Chinuch
      • Birthday
      • Bar Mitzvah
      • Marriage
        • Shidduchim
        • Wedding
        • Chanukas Habayis
        • Mezuzah
      • Wills
      • Mourning (Aveilus)
    • Quick Links
      • Women
      • Brachos List
      • Muktza List
      • Can an Avel (Mourner)…
      • Do I need to Toivel a…
    • Full Database
    • Halacha2go Archives
  • My Questions
    • Sign Up
    • Sign In
  • Donate
  • About Us
  • Podcast
Submit A Question

Mechitzah

  • Children-Chinuch, Mechitzah, Shul, Tznius

עד איזה גיל אפשר להכניס ילדה קטנה לבית הכנסת לעזרת גברים?

  והאם יש בזה הבדל כמה הבית כנסת מלא [למשל ב770 שלפעמים זה ממש צפוף]?   מענה: מעשה רב (בהסכם גדולי ישראל) שגם ילדות קטנות באות עם אבותיהן (לא רק לעזרת…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Tznius
  • concert, mechitza, mixed seating, music, אה"ע כא

What are the guidelines that would make a concert “kosher”?

  Question: My children like music. They express interest in attending concerts. I only feel comfortable if there is no mixed seating. Even if there isn't mixed seating, something about…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Shul
  • ezras nashim, womens section, מעשה רב

Can we make part of the Shul which used to be the mens’ section into the women’ section?

  Question: Women in our shul have complained that they don't have access to the backyard playground from their side of the mechitza. A proposal has been made to move…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Mishte V'Simcha (Festive Meal), Purim, Tznius
  • או"ח תרצה

Attending a Community Purim Seudah

  Question: There is a Purim Seudah planned to take place this year. The way it's set up is family sitting (family per table). I don't know whether there are…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah

My office has a minyan for Mincha and Maariv for many years now, but there is no proper Mechitza in place

  Question: My office has a minyan for mincha and maariv for many years now; however, the space they use for the minyan is the office conference room, which is…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Women
  • ohel

Do women also lift up their hands when saying the Maneh Lashon? Also, maybe there should be a Mechitza at the Ohel?

  Men shouldn’t either. The phrase in the Maane Lashon וישא עיניו אל כפים אל א-ל בשמים is from the passuk in Eicha 3:41, which refers to prayer in general. There…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Shul
  • ezras nashim, womens section

Is a man allowed to daven in the Ezras Nashim (if no women are present)?

  A. Yes. See here: https://asktherav.com/15034-can-a-man-daven-in-the-womens-section/ Q. Does he count for the Minyan?  A. If he is visible to the minyan. Some disagree even if he is visible.   Q.…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah

Is it permitted to daven in a shul that insists on having a low Mechitza?

  Where women would be visible, however, no women are currently present?   Answer: One may daven there when no women are present.   ראה שו"ת מהר"י שטייף סי' קל"ו…

Continue Reading

  • Bentching (Birchas Hamazon), Marriage, Mechitzah, Sheva Brachos, Zimun
  • אה"ע סב

Must we make a Sheva Brachos every day? Must there be a Mechitza?

  Question: We are planning to make a brunch for the mechutamin on the 7th day after the chasuna. They will have had a sheva brachos the night before. Should…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Negiah, Tznius, Wedding
  • siblings

Are siblings (brothers and sisters) allowed to dance together at a wedding?

  The Halacha is that a brother may not hug or kiss a sister or vice versa. This applies to any type of affectionate physical contact between them. Dancing together…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Tznius

How to properly arrange the seating at the Shabbos meal?

  Question: When there are a group of families, bochurim, and older single men and women together for the Shabbos meals, how should they be seated? Is mixed seating allowed?…

Continue Reading

  • Davening, Mechitzah, Shul
  • ezras nashim, womens section

Can a Man Daven in the Women’s Section?

  Question: Aside from the uncomfortable feelings of showing up at shul and seeing men on the women's side... Is it even halachically allowed for men to Daven on the…

Continue Reading

  • Davening, Mechitzah, Mivtzoyim, Tznius

Can I do Mivzoyim if there are people visible which are not Tznius (uncovered hair etc.)?

  Answer: You should not stop them from performing a Mitzvah Medoreiso because of a possibility that there would be someone not tznius. You may ask them to turn around…

Continue Reading

  • Davening, Mechitzah
  • או"ח עה, או"ח צ

Is it permitted to Daven in a public place if there are women there?

  If there are women that are Tznius, it is permitted as long as they are not in your view (provided this isn’t an official shul). עיין חתם סופר בתשובותיו…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Shabbos, Shul
  • Electricity on Shabbos, mechitzah, microphone, reform, tzomet

I do not live so close to a shule. The only nearby shule uses a “Shabbos” microphone. Is there a halachic problem with such a microphone on Shabbos?

  AskTheRav: There are details missing here. What type of shul is this that uses a "Shabbos microphone"? What are their mechitzah standards and other religious standards?   User: Thank…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Shlichus, Shul
  • reform

Can a Shliach try to have Hashpa’ah on a Reform community in such a situation?

  Full Question: On page two of this interview with Rabbi Riskin, he quotes a Psak that Horav Soloveitchik A”H gave him about a frum rabbi sitting in Reform temple,…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Shlichus, Tznius

Are women allowed to give a speech when their audience is 50% men as well? 

  This is not proper for a religious crowd. [1] Poskim advise against this. Some even forbid it outright. [2] However, if the crowd is not religious, and the purpose is…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Tznius
  • comady

Is a random get together of people for comedy purposes allowed? (Comedy show) 

  Yes, if the comedy is clean and there is separate seating between men and women with a Mechitza as explained in question #2806 (2).     #2806 (6)

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah, Tznius
  • concert, mechitza, mixed seating

Are men and women allowed to sit together? (At a concert, event, etc.) 

  Mixed seating for men and women at Jewish events is forbidden and is a breach in Tznius laws. See some of the following sources: Tractate Sukkos 52a where in…

Continue Reading

  • Mechitzah
  • mechitzah, shul

Where does the Rebbe give his ruling about a Mechitzah in a Shul?

  In many places - see references below.   Sources: אג״ק ז ע׳ שט. שם ע׳ שכח. יד ע׳ רכח. יח ע׳ שצד. יט ע׳ עד. כג ע׳ קנו. שם…

Continue Reading

  • Davening, Mechitzah
  • mechitza, shul, transgender

On which side of the Mechitzah does a transgender man sit?

  Question: On which side of the Mechitzah does a transgender man (i.e., someone who was born a woman but identifies herself as a man) sit?   Answer: While there…

Continue Reading

Sponsored By:

Categories

  • - Archives (13)
    • - Charts (3)
    • - Halacha Articles (206)
    • - עברית (604)
    • Ahavas Yisroel (5)
    • Avodah Zarah (166)
      • Gentiles (34)
      • Kishuf (3)
      • Non-Jewish Activities (20)
      • Peyos (Haircut) (10)
    • Bar Mitzvah (33)
    • Beard (7)
    • Beis Hamikdosh (15)
    • Birth (129)
      • Pregnancy (36)
      • Pru U'rvu (5)
      • Names (32)
    • Birthday (12)
    • Bris Milah (49)
    • Chabad Minhogim (3)
    • Chanukah (131)
      • How to Light Menorah? (7)
      • Menorah & Candles (25)
      • When to Light the Menorah? (4)
      • Where to Light Menorah? (13)
      • Who Should Light Menorah? (6)
    • Children-Chinuch (71)
    • Chinuch (41)
    • Choshen Mishpat (264)
      • Borrowing (6)
      • Damages (6)
      • Employer and Employee (6)
      • Geneivas Daas (9)
      • Hasagas Gevul (3)
      • Hashavas Aveida (16)
      • Intellectual Property (8)
      • Loans (9)
      • Nizkei Guf V'Nefesh (9)
      • Renting (3)
      • Sales (23)
      • Shmiras Guf V'Nefesh (37)
      • Stealing (26)
    • Chumros (4)
    • Customs (24)
    • Davening (914)
      • Kavana (2)
      • Gartel (4)
      • Tallis (38)
      • Hefsek in Davening (42)
      • Birchos Hashachar (29)
      • Minyan (47)
      • Kaddish (2)
      • Amen (7)
      • Shacharis (16)
      • Pesukei D'Zimrah (6)
      • Shema (40)
      • Shemoneh Esrei (48)
      • Chazaras Hashatz (22)
      • Kedushah (16)
      • Birchas Kohanim (29)
      • Tachanun (56)
      • Krias Hatorah (179)
        • Aliyos (48)
      • Mincha (12)
      • Maariv (28)
      • Teffilas Haderech (8)
    • Divrei Kedusha (21)
    • Food (24)
    • Geirus (11)
    • Hafrashas Challah (25)
    • Hashem's Name (5)
    • Kashrus (707)
      • Bugs (32)
      • Fish and Meat (12)
      • Fish and Milk (3)
      • Food (32)
      • Health Supplements (7)
      • Hechsher (27)
      • Kashering (63)
      • Kitchen (32)
      • Meat and Milk (116)
        • Time Between Milk/Meat (17)
      • Medicine (10)
      • Orlah (6)
      • Ovens (26)
      • Yayin Nesech\Stam Yeinom (25)
    • Kibud Av V'Em (Honoring Parents) (24)
    • Kilayim (25)
      • Shatnez (18)
    • Lashon Hara (7)
    • Lifnei Iver (4)
    • Lo Yilbash (10)
    • Ma'acholei Akum (Food of Gentiles) (150)
      • Bishul Yisroel (34)
      • Pas Yisroel (18)
      • Cholov Yisroel (16)
      • Tevilas Keilim (78)
    • Marriage (136)
      • Shidduchim (24)
      • Wedding (60)
      • Sheva Brachos (19)
    • Meal (405)
      • Bentching (Birchas Hamazon) (66)
        • Zimun (16)
      • Brochos (Birchas HaNehenin) (270)
        • Besamim (3)
        • Hagomel (23)
      • Netilas Yodayim (Seudah) (37)
    • Medical (75)
      • Alternative Medicine (10)
      • Mental Health (8)
    • Mezuzah (111)
    • Mikvah (Men) (50)
    • Minhogim (3)
    • miscellaneous (1)
    • Mivtzoyim (52)
    • Morning Conduct (19)
    • Moshiach (35)
    • Mourning (Aveilus) (226)
      • Burial (16)
      • Shiva (15)
      • Shloshim (10)
      • Yahrtzeit (36)
      • Year of Aveilus (28)
    • Nachalos (Inheritance) (3)
    • Nedorim (Vows) (15)
    • Negel Vasser (64)
    • Pesach (201)
      • The Month of Nissan (14)
        • Eating Matzah Before Pesach (5)
        • Maos Chitim (2)
        • Birchas Ha'ilanos (4)
        • Saying the Nasi (2)
        • Visiting Kevarim (1)
      • Pesach Preparations (49)
        • Pesach Cleaning (6)
        • Kashering (Pesach) (22)
        • Mechiras Chometz (20)
      • Pesach Foods (32)
        • Gebroks (Shruyah) (2)
        • Hidurim & Chumros (9)
        • Kitniyos (5)
        • Pesach Products (11)
      • Erev Pesach (27)
        • Bedikas/Biur Chometz (11)
        • Foods avoided on (4)
        • Taanis Bechoros (1)
      • Seder (38)
        • Daled Koisos (12)
        • Matzah (12)
        • Marror (2)
        • Afikoman (2)
    • Pidyon Haben (20)
    • Purim (180)
      • Parshas Zachor (8)
      • Taanis Esther (5)
      • Machatzis Hashekel (6)
      • Matanos L'Evyonim (10)
      • Mikrah Megillah (23)
      • Writing a Megillah (6)
      • Mishloach Manos (19)
      • Mishte V'Simcha (Festive Meal) (23)
      • Costumes (3)
    • Rambam (1)
    • Rebbe/Hiskashrus (4)
    • Ribbis (Interest) (26)
    • Rosh Chodesh (59)
      • Kiddush Levana (20)
    • Rosh Hashana (91)
      • Hataras Nedarim (5)
      • Teffilos (7)
      • Simanim (6)
      • Shofar (18)
      • Tashlich (4)
    • Safrus (28)
    • Sakanah (19)
    • Sefer Torah (34)
    • Sefiras HaOmer (151)
      • Counting Omer (15)
      • Clothing (8)
      • Haircut (15)
      • Music (23)
      • Lag Ba'Omer (15)
      • Crossing Dateline (4)
    • Seforim (26)
    • Selichos (9)
    • Shabbos (1476)
      • 39 Melachos (228)
        • Borer (23)
        • Kneading (Losh) (5)
        • Cooking (67)
        • Washing (12)
        • Squeezing (14)
        • Coloring (7)
        • Tying (8)
        • Tearing (14)
        • Writing (8)
        • Erasing (8)
        • Carrying (62)
      • Seder Hayom of Shabbos (115)
        • Erev Shabbos (52)
        • Mincha (3)
        • Motzei Shabbos (58)
          • Havdala (38)
      • Shnayim Mikra (25)
      • Shabbos Candle Lighting (61)
      • Kiddush (68)
      • Amira L'nachri (52)
      • Cleaning (5)
      • Cosmetics (5)
      • Eiruv (19)
      • Food (28)
      • Kitchen Appliances (14)
      • Measuring (5)
      • Muktzeh (66)
      • Musical Instruments (5)
      • Refuah (43)
      • Travel (3)
    • Shavuos (37)
    • Shechita (8)
    • Sheimos (Genizah) (39)
    • Shiluach Haken (4)
    • Shiurim (Classes) (1)
    • Shlichus (67)
    • Shmitah (7)
    • Shul (75)
      • Mechitzah (21)
    • Simchas Torah War (12)
    • Sleep (47)
      • Krias Shema Al Hamita (24)
    • Sukkos (130)
      • Daled Minim (25)
      • Schach (8)
      • Sukkah (47)
    • Taanis Tzibur (Fast Days) (32)
    • Tahara for a Kohen (13)
    • Taharas Hamishpacha (219)
      • Calendar (21)
      • Harchokos (32)
      • Maros (4)
      • Mikvah (Women) (45)
      • Shiva Nekiyim (5)
    • Talmud Torah (79)
      • Chumash (1)
      • Kriah (Alef-Beis & Nekudos) (5)
    • Tefillin (112)
    • Tehillim (24)
    • Terumos and Ma'asros (2)
    • The 3 Weeks (299)
      • Haircut (14)
      • Music (8)
      • Nine Days (112)
      • Shopping (16)
      • Swimming (8)
      • Tisha B'Av (41)
    • Tzar Baalei Chaim (6)
    • Tzavoas Reb Yehuda HaChossid (17)
    • Tzedaka (338)
      • Maaser (238)
        • Separating Ma’aser (52)
        • Spending Ma'aser (78)
    • Tzitzis (64)
    • Tznius (185)
      • Dress Code (13)
      • Kol Isha (11)
      • Negiah (10)
    • Uncategorized (168)
    • Upsherin (16)
    • Wills (2)
    • Women (77)
    • Yichud (39)
    • Yom Kippur (89)
      • Davening (11)
      • Fasting (8)
      • Kaporos (15)
    • Yom Tov (127)
      • Chol Hamoed (28)
      • Candle Lighting (8)
      • Cooking (11)
      • Carrying (3)
    • Zmanim (42)
    AskTheRav
    © Copyright: AskTheRav.com, All Rights Reserved.
    Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Contact Us