People Just Asked
Question: Is there value in saying Shnayim Mikrah on random weeks, and one knows he will not make up the others before Simchas Torah? This is obviously aside from the value of Talmud Torah itself. I'm asking specifically is… Question: Is there value in saying Shnayim Mikrah on random weeks, and one knows he will not make up the others before Simchas Torah? This is obviously aside from the value of Talmud Torah itself. I'm asking specifically is there value within the perspective of the chiyuv/takanah of Shnayim Mikrah. In other words, is it an "all or nothing", as in either one is mashlim everything before Se'udas Shabbos/Mincha Shabbos/Tuesday/Simchas Torah, or they were not "yotze" Shnayim Mikra? Or if one sees one will be able to complete this week's parsha, he should still do…Show more
If this is permissible, does the Kallah need to wash and make hamotzie where the Sheva Brochos will take place? or is it enough if she has in mind to bentch at the Sheva Brochos? Answer: They may… If this is permissible, does the Kallah need to wash and make hamotzie where the Sheva Brochos will take place? or is it enough if she has in mind to bentch at the Sheva Brochos? Answer: They may eat at separate places. When making the bracha hamotzi, she should have a mind that she wishes to continue eating in another location. In the location where the Sheva Brachos will take place, she should eat a bit of bread and Bentch there. #8403Show more
Question: I've noticed there is always a significant time difference when I compare the time of tzeis hakochavim on myzmanim.com versus on chabad.org. Can you explain why this is, and which site is accurate? Answer: The reason for… Question: I've noticed there is always a significant time difference when I compare the time of tzeis hakochavim on myzmanim.com versus on chabad.org. Can you explain why this is, and which site is accurate? Answer: The reason for the difference is due to the various opinions on how to calculate this zman; both websites include many opinions while choosing one to use as its default. (On chabad.org you can click on “Additional Zmanim” to see the other opinions. On myzmanim.com you can click on the green arrow pointing down to see them.) In practice, you may rely…Show more
Question: On Tisha B’Av afternoon I will be flying with my wife and 3 kids westward from NYC and will only be landing at around midnight NY time. I’m wondering if there’s a heter in following my place of… Question: On Tisha B’Av afternoon I will be flying with my wife and 3 kids westward from NYC and will only be landing at around midnight NY time. I’m wondering if there’s a heter in following my place of origin (NYC) in breaking my fast. I did see that some seem to allow it but I don’t want to misunderstand anything. Answer: While it is true that some are lenient in such a case, most Poskim disagree and state that one should break the fast at nightfall of place of arrival even when traveling westbound. However, in a…Show more
Yes, they may be buried in the Jewish cemetery. There is a prevalent myth out there that people with tattoos may not be buried in a Jewish cemetery. This is absolutely untrue. Although people with tattoos are in violation… Yes, they may be buried in the Jewish cemetery. There is a prevalent myth out there that people with tattoos may not be buried in a Jewish cemetery. This is absolutely untrue. Although people with tattoos are in violation of a serious prohibition in the Torah, that does not preclude their right to being buried in a Jewish cemetery. It is possible that this myth has developed due to the fact that tattooing has an association with idolatry. Alternatively, there are some Jewish burial societies who may insist on certain standards of who may be buried in their cemeteries.…Show more
Yes. In fact, there is a Minhag to pass one's finger over one's teeth while reciting the words "כך לא יוכלו כל אויבי לנגוע בי לרעה". Sources: בכלל, זהירות בקידוש לבנה היא סגולה לשנים - ראה…
Question: Due to the pandemic, is taking a shower before going into the Mikva during the nine days (for no other reason than to uphold the hygiene of the Mikva water) allowed, forbidden or a Chiyuv? Answer: As… Question: Due to the pandemic, is taking a shower before going into the Mikva during the nine days (for no other reason than to uphold the hygiene of the Mikva water) allowed, forbidden or a Chiyuv? Answer: As far as I understand, there is no medical imperative to act differently in this regard due to the pandemic. To quote one of the doctors I consulted on the matter: In terms of showering, I really cannot think why this year should be any different. The main spread is through people who are sick, and other than making sure that…Show more
No. משנ"ב תקנא, סקמ"ה: ובגדים שאינם חשובים כ״כ שא״צ לברך עליו שהחיינו כגון מנעלים חדשים ואנפלאות וכיו״ב בודאי מותר לקנותו וללבשו מי״ז בתמוז עד ר״ח. #10102
If you do so every week, you may do it during the nine days as well. Source: ראה שו"ת התעוררות תשובה ח"ג סי' ל', מועדים וזמנים ח"ח ע' פ"ה, ועוד. #10118
No, as the laws of the three weeks apply on the night before the fast. Source: ראה מש"כ באשל-אברהם להרה"צ מבוטשאטש או"ח סי' תקנ"א, שו"ת ציץ-אליעזר ח"י סי' כ"ו, ומאידך ראה מש"כ בשו"ת אגרות-משה או"ח ח"א סי' קס"ח… No, as the laws of the three weeks apply on the night before the fast. Source: ראה מש"כ באשל-אברהם להרה"צ מבוטשאטש או"ח סי' תקנ"א, שו"ת ציץ-אליעזר ח"י סי' כ"ו, ומאידך ראה מש"כ בשו"ת אגרות-משה או"ח ח"א סי' קס"ח וח"ד סי' קי"ב היכא שיש צורך. והעיקר כנ״ל. https://asktherav.com/15092-do-the-dinim-of-the-three-weeks-apply-from-the-night-before-the-fast/ #10146Show more
שאלה: האם מותר להזמין בתשעת הימים בגד באתר אינטרנט, כאשר הבגד יגיע רק לאחר תשעת הימים? מדובר בבגד לחתונה בט"ו מנ"א ואם יוזמן לאחר תשעת הימים, לא בטוח שיגיע לחתונה... מענה: מעיקר הדין צריך לקנותן רק לאחר תשעה… שאלה: האם מותר להזמין בתשעת הימים בגד באתר אינטרנט, כאשר הבגד יגיע רק לאחר תשעת הימים? מדובר בבגד לחתונה בט"ו מנ"א ואם יוזמן לאחר תשעת הימים, לא בטוח שיגיע לחתונה... מענה: מעיקר הדין צריך לקנותן רק לאחר תשעה באב. אבל כשאי אפשר ויש חשש שלא יגיע בזמן מותר. וראה מ"ש באנגלית בלינק המצורף: https://asktherav.com/5038-can-one-go-shopping-during-the-nine-days-to-outlets-with-big-sales/ מקורות: משנה ברורה תקנא, מט: אסור לקנותן – אפילו דעתו…Show more
No. שו״ע או״ח תקנא, ב. #10170
Strictly speaking it is permitted, but is discouraged, as one should avoid activities which pose a danger during the nine days. Effort should be made that only face, hands and feet become wet, or only a minor portion of… Strictly speaking it is permitted, but is discouraged, as one should avoid activities which pose a danger during the nine days. Effort should be made that only face, hands and feet become wet, or only a minor portion of the body. See here: https://asktherav.com/570-i-direct-a-yeshivas-kayitz-and-the-head-counselor-planned-a-trip-of-horseback-riding-for-one-of-the-nine-days-is-this-a-problem-also-is-it-okay-instead-of-swimming-to-have-the-boys-play-in-water/ #10156Show more
Question: I don't doubt the Rebbe's words for a second, I am only asking so I can understand and explain to others: We can't give away parts of Eretz Yisroel because this is something that Hashem gave to us,… Question: I don't doubt the Rebbe's words for a second, I am only asking so I can understand and explain to others: We can't give away parts of Eretz Yisroel because this is something that Hashem gave to us, the Jewish people. This is in short, I think, the Rebbe's view on the topic. If so, how is this a reason for not giving away land? If someone gives me something, it is mine completely and I can do with it as I wish. If we were given Ba'alus over Eretz Yisroel, why can't we give parts of or…Show more
Question: If I forgot to say Ha'etz on a fruit and said Hoadama already on a vegetable negating the order of brachos, am I still able to say Ha'etz or it was inadvertently been covered and my Ha'etz… Question: If I forgot to say Ha'etz on a fruit and said Hoadama already on a vegetable negating the order of brachos, am I still able to say Ha'etz or it was inadvertently been covered and my Ha'etz would be a bracha l'vatalah? Is it true for all brachos and the orders? Answer: You should still say Ha'etz, because Hoadama only works for the fruit if you say it on the fruit itself (or according to some also if you specifically have it in mind, but not where it was recited on the Hoadama without…Show more
Question: A lady who recently became observant used to play a musical instrument and give concerts in front of a general, mixed audience. Is it OK to continue doing so, or is it not tznius? She does not… Question: A lady who recently became observant used to play a musical instrument and give concerts in front of a general, mixed audience. Is it OK to continue doing so, or is it not tznius? She does not sing. Answer: First of all, it is forbidden for anyone to perform for, or attend a performance in, a mixed audience. Additionally, it is forbidden for women to perform in front of men. This refers to doing any special skills that can attract the attention of men to their movements. This is part of the prohibition of "in front…Show more
There is no official original source for this custom. See discussion below. However, this is a widespread custom, quoted in numerous places. Sources: ראה מחזור ויטרי עמוד 256 הלכות פסח אות י.…
The Rebbe was asked this question and responded that if one asks this question, that itself is an indication that the questioner lacks the "hergesh" (feeling). Practically, this question might be better answered by your personal mashpia… The Rebbe was asked this question and responded that if one asks this question, that itself is an indication that the questioner lacks the "hergesh" (feeling). Practically, this question might be better answered by your personal mashpia. מענה מט' תמוז תשמ"ט: ״בענינים התלוים ברגש - אין לשאול כיון שזוהי הוכחה שאין רגש״. #15365Show more
If the dirt, etc. hasn't dried yet, you may leave them to soak in water. You may rinse them, if you are afraid of attracting insects, or of the dishes getting ruined. See here as well: https://asktherav.com/9185-is-one-allowed-to-wash-the-dishes-friday-night-after-the-shabbos-meal-and-put-them-in-the-dishwasher/ Sources: ראה שש"כ פרק יב סעיפים ב-ג, ועיין בשוע"ר סימן…
Yes, unless it was a barren tree before, or - according to some opinions - it was planted before Klal Yisroel arrived to Eretz Yisroel (at least in areas which were originally not part of Eretz Yisroel, or were… Yes, unless it was a barren tree before, or - according to some opinions - it was planted before Klal Yisroel arrived to Eretz Yisroel (at least in areas which were originally not part of Eretz Yisroel, or were conquered through Yehoshua but not subsequently through the olei Bavel). During the second era of Yemos HaMashiach, after the final resurrection, some maintain there will be no prohibition against Orlah or other Mitzvos. Sources: ידוע השקו״ט מהי התועלת בעץ נטוע ועושה פירות בן…Show more
Question: I need to do a training class for my business which requires knowledge of 50 different examples of wine from around the world. The wine is stam yeinom. Many of the examples would be available in… Question: I need to do a training class for my business which requires knowledge of 50 different examples of wine from around the world. The wine is stam yeinom. Many of the examples would be available in kosher but I can’t bring them to the class and it would cost me a lot of money to buy them all. I heard that a woman can taste food on a fast day and spit it out and this shows that she doesn’t want to have benefit from it. Can I taste and spit the stam yeinom examples in…Show more
There is an argument amongst contemporary poskim if one is allowed to open it on Shabbos. In practice, one should open it before Shabbos. If one forgot to do so, there is room for leniency to do it on… There is an argument amongst contemporary poskim if one is allowed to open it on Shabbos. In practice, one should open it before Shabbos. If one forgot to do so, there is room for leniency to do it on Shabbos. However, even then it is best to cut or rip the entire top of the carton and avoid the issue. See here for similar topic: https://asktherav.com/is-one-allowed-to-pull-open-the-seal-of-a-carton-orange-juice-bottle-on-shabbos-i-am-referring-to-the-seal-under-the-cap-that-you-need-to-pull-hard-to-rip-off-3381/ Sources: כמה צדדי היתר, כנז׳ שם בלינק הנ״ל, ובפרטיות: שיש מתירים…Show more
שאלה: ילמדנו רבינו, האם ישנו חיוב ע"פ הלכה (ולא רק ע"פ פנימיות הענינים - שזה מוסיף חיות וכו') לקבל מלכותו של מי שהוא חזקת משיח? ובאם כן במה מתבטא קבלת מלכות זו. האם זה כמו כל החזקות שבתורה, והלא… שאלה: ילמדנו רבינו, האם ישנו חיוב ע"פ הלכה (ולא רק ע"פ פנימיות הענינים - שזה מוסיף חיות וכו') לקבל מלכותו של מי שהוא חזקת משיח? ובאם כן במה מתבטא קבלת מלכות זו. האם זה כמו כל החזקות שבתורה, והלא בד"כ בחזקות אין צריכים לעשות עוד פעולות לברר החזקה? [היינו האם הכוונה "בחזקת" הוא שבעינינו מחזיקים אותו כמשיח, או שיש לו חזקה שהוא המשיח?] תשובה: מסתבר לומר שאם יש מישהו שהוא בחזקת משיח חייבים להאמין בו, כד׳ הרמב״ם רפי״א, ובפשוטו הוא להאמין ולחכות שיתקיימו על ידו שאר הסימנים, שכיון שהמלך המשיח עתיד לעמוד ולהחזיר מלכות בית דוד, ומי שאינו…Show more
Question: If one ate two foods that each one needs M’ain Shalosh, (for example, figs and mezonos, etc), but only mentioned one type when starting the bracha and then in the middle of the bracha remembered the second… Question: If one ate two foods that each one needs M’ain Shalosh, (for example, figs and mezonos, etc), but only mentioned one type when starting the bracha and then in the middle of the bracha remembered the second type, what is the proper procedure at that point: should he add it in at the end, or should he just finish with what he started and make the bracha again? Answer: You should go back to the beginning after the opening words “Baruch Ato etc. Melech Haloam” and mention both categories of food. If one already finished the…Show more
Question: I feel very badly because while I was trying to affix a mezuzah, it went on the ground briefly. I had put it on top of my phone which was resting on the ground as I was going… Question: I feel very badly because while I was trying to affix a mezuzah, it went on the ground briefly. I had put it on top of my phone which was resting on the ground as I was going to put it up on a doorway outside. But then I accidentally made it roll off to the ground. It was wrapped only in parchment. Is there anything I should do? Also is it ok that I then put up that same Mezuzah already? Answer: The idea of fasting when holy objects fall to the ground G-D forbid is…Show more
Have a Halachic Question?
Submit your question and receive an answer shortly.
Submit A Question
