« go back

I left a bottle of wine on my desk overnight, Can I use it?

 

Full Question:

I left non mevushal wine in an open brown bag on my desk in school overnight. There are non Jewish janitors that clean the room each day after everyone leaves.

Can I use the wine or should I throw it out?

 

Answer:

If the wine is still sealed, or if it certainly wasn’t touched (and seen) by a non-Jew (i.e., it is clear that it remained inside the bag the entire time), it is permissible.

Otherwise, if it’s known that the wine was touched by a non-Jew, it should not be used and it must be discarded.

If it was merely seen by a non-Jew, it is permitted, but some have a stringency not to use it for kiddush or other kos shel bracha. Many chassidim practice this stringency. Others are particular not to use at all.

See also here:

My cleaning help saw a bottle of non-Mevushal wine on my dining room table but she did not touch it. Can it be used for Kiddush? Can it be used just as a drink?

 

 

#13426


Add Comment

Your Email address will not be published