What is the proper way to sell things in a Yeshivah canteen on Shabbos?

 

The point of the canteen is to give access to kosher food to the students that need that availability. There is also a point or ticket system that they are rewarded with, that they can redeem in the canteen. They can get food with cash as well.

 

Answer:

They can pick up items in the canteen and pay after Shabbos. They should not mention price or measurement.

The canteen should find a method of keeping a record through paperclips etc.

Using points is OK. But it is questionable whether one may use special Yeshiva dollars or vouchers. See here for more on that:

Halacha2go.com article #357: Fake Money on Shabbos

 

וראה שו״ע אדה״ז סי׳ שכג.

 

 

#2412


Comments (2)

  • Abraham June 16, 2022 - 3 years ago

    Seemingly fake money should also be a problem of mukzta even though it cannot be used for buying and selling, being that the reason that real money is muktza is not that it can be used for buying and selling (because then it would be considered a כלי שמלאכתו לאיסור) but rather because it is not considered a כלי, and if that’s the case, and fake money should (-all the more so-) not be considered a כלי, therefore rendering it מוקצה מחמת איסור?

    (And if that is true, it would be forbidden to move as well, not just to use/play with)

    Would that be a valid problem?

    • AskTheRav June 16, 2022 - 3 years ago

      It’s not clear if fake money would be muktza as well, though there is strong reasons that it wouldn’t be.

      הנה, מעות הם בגדר מוקצה מחמת גופו. ובפמ״ג במ״ז רסי׳ שח מבאר שאין עליו תורת כלי, כיון שאא״פ להשתמש בו, ורק שאפשר לקנות על ידו. ובכסף מדומה, הרי תשמישו למשחק. ואינו אסור אלא שטוב למנוע וכו’ ולכמה פוסקים ה”ז מותר כיון שהוא משחק – ראה בשש”כ פט”ז, לג ובהערה שם.

Comments are closed.